
Well, we’re well in to Season 4 of the Doctor Who, Tennant has made the part his own in a way that, in my opinion, hasn’t happened since Peter Davison, who I rate as the last decent Doctor, and we have a new companion in the loud brash form of Catherine Tate.
Let me deal with Tate first. When I first heard the news that they were going to use her as the new companion for the whole of series 4, well, I kind of grit my teeth a little. I’m not the greatest fan of her sketch show, and she was poorly written in The Runaway Bride – honestly I hadn’t had such a bad feeling about a companion since bloody Bonnie Langford. Was the good Doctor about to jump the shark with his Tardis?
Well, no, and thank the bloody dead and gone Time Lords that the creative team haven’t taken a huge creative misstep. In my humble view for what its worth, I think Tate was exactly what the show needed. A quality, talented character foil, who can do both comedy and drama effortlessly within seconds of dialogue.
In the past I’d always hated it when the stories tried to do comedy, quite frankly it always looked naff and forced. The last time anyone got any comedy right in Who was back in the seventies when the immortal Douglas Adams was penning the stories – if you don’t believe me check out City of Death from the Tom Baker years which was one of the finest comedy Who stories ever, its worth the price alone for the John Cleese cameo with his modern art critique.
Tenant and Tate have chemistry, they obviously love working with each other and had done a great Comic relief skit together, and quite clearly Russell Davies (show runner) clearly saw the potential of mining that special relationship for all he could.
Episode 1 Partners in Crime
The openers are usually pretty lame in Doctor Who, if I’m being brutally honest. They’re usually light romps designed to introduce companions or a new Doctor and rarely become dramatic in the way that stories like Father’s Day or Human Nature do.
This one had all the makings of an all time bucket of swill of an opener. I mean come on - Raquel from bloody Corrie? You half expect her to start whining for Curly or something? A sonic pen? It may as well have been sonic eye liner. And Aliens made from fat? What more fart gags? I know the show is supposed to be for kids as much as adults – but the word really juvenile springs to mind.
Somehow though it worked – the humor out of the Doctor and Donna missing each other worked pretty well. There was less shouty stuff from Donna than before, and with the help of Bernard Cribbins as her grandfather, Davies managed to add some nuance to her character, something that seemed impossible back in the special.
The aliens were kind of cute and worked well with in the context of the story and mood he was aiming for.
The plot though was throwaway material really, and was merely a prologue for Donna’s story and the beautiful set up for the main story arc of the series - the return of Rose.
Best moment – Dr: I just want a mate.
Donna: Well you’re not mating with me sunshine!
Clearly these two together are going to have fun and the next episode doesn’t disappoint.
Episode 2 The Fires of Pompeii
Its become a bit of a pattern now that we get a historical episode in the second outing of a series. This one though is possibly one of my favorite stories of new Who. Seriously, they made this thing look like a million dollars. Its epic, ballsey and adds tonnes of story arc development.
The Doctor and Donna are supposed to go to Ancient Rome, but end up in Pompeii instead. To make matters worse it's the day before Vesuvius erupts. They decide that a quick exit would be the best idea, only to find the Tardis has been sold to a lover of modern art. As the plot unfurls we get Soothsayers, Volcanic rock monsters and a healthy dose of moral dilemmas about saving lives and not interfering with the time stream.
Donna’s role as companion here sees some great development. First off she experiments with the language translation that the Tardis gives its crew; what would Latin sound like when its translated? Well apparently it sounds Welsh.
Donna of course wants to warn the inhabitants about the impending disaster. Naturally the Doctor says they can’t, as it's a fixed point in history. Donna’s age and experience here shows she’s not willing to accept everything he says and is much less doe eyed in acceptance of his explanations unlike Rose and Martha on occasion. This plays through the whole episode and for the first time we get a rational argument for why the Doctor can change some things and not others. It all leads in to decent climax that is well, erm - explosive.
It all works brilliantly quite frankly aided by a great supporting cast. I’ve always been a big fan of Phil Davis, and he scowls and spits as good as always as the villain.
The dialogue is sharp, and there is some beautiful word play early on between the Doctor and the psychics, which illuminate key arc words for the rest of the series. I won’t ruin it for you but the bit about the Medusa Cascade is sweet as.
Anything bad about it? Well not really, some of the Roman family stuff is a bit on the cringe worthy side, with some redundant scenes that could have been exorcised with some judicious editing, but basically a brilliant second episode.
Episode 3 The Planet of The Ood or We want to save money so lets reuse some old prosthetics from season 2 before they go moldy and lets use another refinery for an alien base – yawn.
Here we end up on the Ood Sphere where the Doctor gets all sanctimonious about using slaves and is on the whole pretty useless throughout the whole episode, as it appears the rebellion of the Ood against the humans has been well planned out and executed without any Time Lord interference.
That’s about it really. There’s a bit of running about and shouting. Some lame action sequences, Donna cries again, and Tim Mckinnery loses his hair and head.
I’m probably being a bit too hard on this one, but seriously it doesn’t really stretch the characters very much, and we’ve been and here and seen this a dozen times before. Seriously we get it – humans are bad and some aliens are good.
Episode 4 and 5 The Sonataran Stratagem and The Poison Sky
Well this is much better. Martha’s back, UNIT’s back sans the Brigadier, and more importantly we get Sonatarans – the potato head bunch of stomping clone warriors are back.
This could have been two episodes of more swill, after all Helen Raynor wrote them and she is responsible for the excretable Daleks in Manhattan and the even more diahorretic Evolution of The Daleks. Apparently the reason they were the remains of Dehli Belly wasn’t her fault, but well her name is on the titles so take it like a woman Raynor that's what I say.
Anyhow, the first two parter of the series is much better than in season 3. They’re action packed, filled with interesting soft sci-fi concepts and some decent characters to boot.
The plot is simple; the Sonotarans want the Earth as a new cloning world for their war effort against the Rutans. They use seriously annoying boy Genius Rattcliffe to fix 400 million cars with ATMOS which is supposed to convert CO2 emissions into harmless gas, but is in fact got a cunning temporal trick switch which will release a poisonous gas which is suitable for the nourishing billions of Sonotaran clones. Phew, that’s a lot of story. I think I just blew the cover off the Sonotaran’s secret plan, but honestly speaking it will make very little difference with enjoying this essentially big and loud action story.
Along the way Martha gets cloned and covered in gooey stuff. Donna shows that working for a temping agency can help solve world threatening mysteries, and the Doctor gets all sanctimonious about guns.
This is actually rather irritating as obviously he’s starting to develop dementia in his old age, as he never had a problem with them in Attack of the Cybermen, and even more recently Dalek, not to mention the Time War where he must have used quite a few of them. Actually this was a huge bugbear for me. I understand the Doctor wants to solve things without violence and guns, that’s part of his genius – but seriously we’ve been here before and well guns can be quite useful when you’re dealing with daleks and such like really, so I’m at a loss to see why he makes such a sing and dance about this time. Bad writing if you ask me.
Episode 6 The Doctor’s daughter
Well, the title says it all really. We get to meet quite literally the daughter of our Doctor, who also happens to be played by the real life daughter of Peter Davison, which is a nice casting coup for the production team, don’t you think? She’s rather tasty too. Certainly David Tennant thinks so as he’s now dating her. Don’t even start to work out the incestuous nature of that relationship – think about it, Tenth Doctor shagging Fifth Doctor’s real daughter – go on make all the jokes you can I’m sure they are. LOL.
Sorry, beyond the tabloid fun, the story itself is surprisingly old school seventies fair – reminded me a bit of Underworld and other lost Earth Colony stories from the seventies. So so denouement, and mercifully they don’t waste a fine addition to the Who Mythos by killing Jenny (the daughter) in the final scenes. Apparently new show runner Moffat ordered a rewrite of the ending so that he can use her in the future.
Martha and Donna are kind of second stringers in this one. Martha gets thrown around a lot, captured by giant fish who blow bubbles, dunked in alien quick sand and basically has really rough time of it. Donna on the other hand shows that being a temp isn’t a colossal waste of time after all, and does her usual bit as the Doctor’s conscience.
Essentially its Jenny’s show, a great introduction to a character who I hope we see a lot more of. A lot of people had been hoping that there would be continuity links with Susan, the Doctor’s long gone dgranddaughter, but quite frankly it would have been uber fanwanky and this strategy of creating a new mythology for the Doctor is far smarter move on the production team’s part IMHO.
Recent Comments